Dr James Ryan
Senior Lecturer in Modern European (Russian) History (Study Leave 2022/3)
School of History, Archaeology and Religion
- Available for postgraduate supervision
Overview
I am a historian of modern Russia, and more specifically Soviet Russia between the world wars. My published work is mainly in the intellectual history of Soviet political violence. I seek to understand how it was possible for the Soviet state to become the most violent and destructive regime in modern peacetime European history.
More generally, the strands of my research and teaching interests can be grouped as follows:
*Political violence and repression; ideology; dictatorship; secrecy; criminological thought
*Intellectual history
*Historical memory and the politics of history, especially in contemporary Russia
My first book was a comprehensive study of violence in the political thought of V.I. Lenin, the Bolshevik Party leader and effective first leader of the Soviet state, with the title Lenin's Terror: The Ideological Origins of Early Soviet State Violence (London, 2012). In that book I examined the development of Lenin's views on political violence from the 1890s until the 1920s in relation to the political crises of Russia and Europe more generally during that time. I argued that the particular nature of Leninist ideology provides the primary explanation for the creation of the Soviet state as a violent dictatorship.
My current monograph project bears the provisional title, 'We value and love life too much': An Intellectual History of Soviet State Violence, 1917-1939. This book is the first, full-length intellectual history of Soviet state violence during the most brutal period of the state’s history. It examines the fascinating and complex relationship between political violence and Bolshevik thought, identity, and political practices. This includes how and why repression and its underpinning dictatorship were justified, excused, and criticized - and sometimes left unspoken. And it includes how those conceptions, rhetorica strategies, and discursive parameters developed over a twenty-year period.
As such, it contributes to our understanding of the tragic first half of twentieth-century European history. It reflects on the nature, preconditions, and consequences of mass political violence; how political extremism is possible; and how human beings individually and collectively can perpetrate extraordinary levels of political brutality.
In addition to my work on Soviet state violence, I am very interested in the politics of history and the significance of collective memory. In particular, I follow discussions about the Soviet past in Russia today. I have written about the Russian government's commemoration of the centenary of the Russian Revolution, and about perceptions of Stalin and Stalinism in contemporary Russia.
In my teaching, I offer a second-year undergraduate module that takes a broad look at the history of Russia's twentieth century, and a third-year advanced option module that looks more specifically at my current book project, the relationship between violence and ideology in inter-war Soviet Russia.
In the academic year 2022-23 I will take up a Gerda Henkel Foundation Scholarship to begin work on chapters in the final part of my monograph project, and I will not be teaching.
Publication
2023
- Ryan, J. 2023. The politics of national history: Russia's ruling elite and the centenary of 1917. In: Leonard, C. S. and Orlovsky, D. eds. The Russian Revolution of 1917: Memory and Legacy. New York and Abingdon: Routledge
2020
- Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. 2020. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, contradictions, and controversies. London: Bloomsbury.
- Ryan, J. 2020. Reckoning with the past: Stalin and Stalinism in Putin's Russia. In: Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, Contradictions, and Controversies. London: Bloomsbury, pp. 157-172.
- Ryan, J. and Grant, S. 2020. Introduction: revisioning Stalin and Stalinism. In: Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, Contradictions, and Controversies. Bloomsbury, pp. 1-20.
- Ryan, J. 2020. Lenin y el leninismo: una perspectiva a partir del centenario de la Revolucion Rusa. In: Pinto, S. A. ed. La Revolucion Bolchevique y America Latina: Apropriaciones, experiencias y trayectorias. Santiago de Chile: RiL editores, pp. 37-59.
2018
- Ryan, J. 2018. 'War against war': The significance of the First World War in the thought of V.I. Lenin on violence, 1914-1921. In: Read, C., Waldron, P. and Lindenmeyr, A. eds. Russia's Home Front in War and Revolution, 1914-1922: Book 4: Reintegration - The Struggle for the State. Russia's Great War and Revolution Slavica Publishing, pp. 256-278.
- Ryan, J. 2018. The politics of national history: Russia's ruling elite and the centenary of 1917. Revolutionary Russia 31(1), pp. 24-45. (10.1080/09546545.2018.1480115)
- Ryan, J. 2018. Goodbye Lenin? A centenary perspective. History Today 68(6), pp. 40-52.
2017
- Ryan, J. 2017. 'They know not what they do'? Bolshevik understandings of the agency of perpetrators, 1918-1930. Historical Research 90(247), pp. 151-171. (10.1111/1468-2281.12164)
- Ryan, J. 2017. Lenin and Leninism: a centenary perspective'. In transliterated Latin script, it is 'Lenin i leninizm: vzgliad cherez stoletie. In: Shapovalova, L. D. ed. 1917: State. Power. Territory: Papers of the International Conference 25 October 2017. ROSSPEN (Moscow), pp. 269-277.
2015
- Ryan, J. 2015. The sacralization of violence: Bolshevik justifications for violence and terror during the Civil War. Slavic Review 74(4), pp. 808-831. (10.5612/slavicreview.74.4.808)
2013
- Ryan, J. 2013. Cleansing NEP Russia: State Violence against the Russian Orthodox Church in 1922. Europe-Asia Studies 65(9), pp. 1807-1826. (10.1080/09668136.2013.842364)
2012
- Ryan, J. 2012. Lenin's terror: the ideological origins of early Soviet state violence. London and Abingdon: Routledge.
2011
- Ryan, J. 2011. 'Revolution is war': the development of the thought of V.I. Lenin on violence, 1899-1907. Slavonic and East European Review 89(2), pp. 248-273. (10.5699/slaveasteurorev2.89.2.0248)
2007
- Ryan, J. 2007. Lenin's "The State and Revolution" and Soviet state violence: a textual analysis. Revolutionary Russia 20(2), pp. 151-172. (10.1080/09546540701633452)
Articles
- Ryan, J. 2018. The politics of national history: Russia's ruling elite and the centenary of 1917. Revolutionary Russia 31(1), pp. 24-45. (10.1080/09546545.2018.1480115)
- Ryan, J. 2018. Goodbye Lenin? A centenary perspective. History Today 68(6), pp. 40-52.
- Ryan, J. 2017. 'They know not what they do'? Bolshevik understandings of the agency of perpetrators, 1918-1930. Historical Research 90(247), pp. 151-171. (10.1111/1468-2281.12164)
- Ryan, J. 2015. The sacralization of violence: Bolshevik justifications for violence and terror during the Civil War. Slavic Review 74(4), pp. 808-831. (10.5612/slavicreview.74.4.808)
- Ryan, J. 2013. Cleansing NEP Russia: State Violence against the Russian Orthodox Church in 1922. Europe-Asia Studies 65(9), pp. 1807-1826. (10.1080/09668136.2013.842364)
- Ryan, J. 2011. 'Revolution is war': the development of the thought of V.I. Lenin on violence, 1899-1907. Slavonic and East European Review 89(2), pp. 248-273. (10.5699/slaveasteurorev2.89.2.0248)
- Ryan, J. 2007. Lenin's "The State and Revolution" and Soviet state violence: a textual analysis. Revolutionary Russia 20(2), pp. 151-172. (10.1080/09546540701633452)
Book sections
- Ryan, J. 2023. The politics of national history: Russia's ruling elite and the centenary of 1917. In: Leonard, C. S. and Orlovsky, D. eds. The Russian Revolution of 1917: Memory and Legacy. New York and Abingdon: Routledge
- Ryan, J. 2020. Reckoning with the past: Stalin and Stalinism in Putin's Russia. In: Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, Contradictions, and Controversies. London: Bloomsbury, pp. 157-172.
- Ryan, J. and Grant, S. 2020. Introduction: revisioning Stalin and Stalinism. In: Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, Contradictions, and Controversies. Bloomsbury, pp. 1-20.
- Ryan, J. 2020. Lenin y el leninismo: una perspectiva a partir del centenario de la Revolucion Rusa. In: Pinto, S. A. ed. La Revolucion Bolchevique y America Latina: Apropriaciones, experiencias y trayectorias. Santiago de Chile: RiL editores, pp. 37-59.
- Ryan, J. 2018. 'War against war': The significance of the First World War in the thought of V.I. Lenin on violence, 1914-1921. In: Read, C., Waldron, P. and Lindenmeyr, A. eds. Russia's Home Front in War and Revolution, 1914-1922: Book 4: Reintegration - The Struggle for the State. Russia's Great War and Revolution Slavica Publishing, pp. 256-278.
- Ryan, J. 2017. Lenin and Leninism: a centenary perspective'. In transliterated Latin script, it is 'Lenin i leninizm: vzgliad cherez stoletie. In: Shapovalova, L. D. ed. 1917: State. Power. Territory: Papers of the International Conference 25 October 2017. ROSSPEN (Moscow), pp. 269-277.
Books
- Ryan, J. and Grant, S. eds. 2020. Revisioning Stalin and Stalinism: Complexities, contradictions, and controversies. London: Bloomsbury.
- Ryan, J. 2012. Lenin's terror: the ideological origins of early Soviet state violence. London and Abingdon: Routledge.
Research
Research projects
'We value and love life too much': An Intellectual History of Soviet State Violence, 1917-1939
In the late 1950s the Moscow-based literary critic, Andrei Siniavskii, wrote a striking critique of the foundational logic of the Soviet regime. 'So that prisons would disappear forever,' he remarked, using a pseudonym, 'we built new prisons.' So that work would become pleasurable, he continued, 'we introduced penal labour.' And so that 'not a single drop of blood would spill again,' he intoned, 'we killed, killed and killed.'
Russia's October Revolution of 1917 represented the most ambitious and sustained attempt at human transformation and emancipation in modern European history. Coming to power at a time of unprecedented warf, the new ruling Bolshevik Party was inspired by the idea of the complete liberation of Russia - and humanity in general - from all forms of exploitation and suffering. Bolsheviks believed that exploitative socio-economic structures were the root cause of war, violence, crime, and disorder. THeir envisioned socialism would remove the very possibility of violence, as it would give true meaning to the dignity and value of life itself. However, the Soviet state would become the most violent in peacetime modern European history. This was the great paradox of the Russian Revolution, captured so eloquently by Siniavskii. It was the great paradox perhaps of twentieth century politics. But how was it possible?
I am writing a wide-ranging book that will provide the most complete, in-depth analysis of that question: the first specific intellectual history of inter-war Soviet state violence. My work examines the fascinating relationship between political violence and Bolshevik thought, identity, and political practices. This includes how and why repression and its underpinning dictatorship were justified, excused, and criticised – and sometimes left unspoken. And it includes how those conceptions, rhetorical strategies, and discursive parameters developed over a period of twenty years.
The book contributes to our understanding of the tragic first half of twentieth-century European history. It reflects on the nature, preconditions, and consequences of mass political violence; how political extremism is possible; and how human beings individually and collectively can perpetrate extraordinary levels of political brutality.
In the academic year 2022-23, I will take up a Scholarship provided by the Gerda Henkel Stiftung in Germany to begin work on chapters in the final part of the book. I also intend to use this time to complete an article about the significance of secrecy and transparency in the intellectual history of inter-war Soviet state violence.
Teaching
In 2022-23, I will take up a research scholarship and will not be teaching.
- HS1776 The Soviet Century
- HS1883 Violence and Ideology in Inter-War Soviet Russia
- HS1107 History in Practice
- HS1105 Making of the Modern World
- HS1801 Dissertations
Teaching profile
My teaching focuses on modern Russian and especially Soviet history, with an emphasis on notions of cultural revolution; political violence; ideology; and economic factors in political decision-making. My teaching also engages with political violence and related issues in a broader, comparative context. I would be happy to supervise students in any of these areas.
Biography
Education and qualifications
2010: Ph.D Modern History, National University of Ireland (Cork)
2005: BA (Hons), First Class, National University of Ireland (Cork)
Career overview
2018- Senior Lecturer in Modern European (Russian) History, Cardiff University
2014-2018: Lecturer in Modern European (Russian) History, Cardiff University
2011-2014: Government of Ireland/Marie Curie COFUND Postdoctoral Mobility Research Fellow in the Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Warwick and University College Cork
2010-2011: Assistant Lecturer, School of History, University College Cork
Honours and awards
2022-23: Gerda Henkel Stiftung Research Scholarship for 'The "Great Turning Point": Rites of Repression and Repentance in Early Stalinism
2021: Fellowship at the Imre Kertesz Kolleg, University of Jena, Germany (declined, due to Covid)
2017: Elected Fellow of the Royal Historical Society (FRHistS)
2015-17: Erasmus Plus International Credit Mobility Scheme award to oversee teaching exchange partnership between SHARE, Cardiff University, and the History Faculty, State Academic University for the Humanities, Russian Academy of Sciences
2011-14: Government of Ireland/Marie Curie CARA Postdoctoral Mobility Research Fellowship
2007-9: Government of Ireland Postgraduate Research Scholarship
2005-7: Faculty of Arts Postgraduate Research Scholarship, University College Cork
Professional memberships
- Fellow of the Royal Historical Society (FRHistS)
- Fellow of the Higher Education Academy (HEA)
- Member of the Association for Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies (ASEEES)
- Member of the British Association for Slavonic and East European Studies (BASEES)
- Member of the BASEES Study Group on the Russian Revolution
- Member of the Irish Association for Russian, Central and East European Studies (IARCEES)
- Member of the Irish Association of Professional Historians (IAPH)
Since 2015, I have been reviews editor for the journal Revolutionary Russia.
Supervisions
I am interested in supervising PhD students in the following areas:
* Various themes in the political, intellectual, cultural, social, economic, and legal history of the inter-war Soviet Union
* Political violence in modern Russian and Soviet history
* History and memory in post-Soviet Russia and the former Soviet Union